Italian Restaurants in Middletown

It's Only Natural Restaurant -

386 Main Street - Middletown

It's Only Natural Restaurant specializes in fresh, healthy vegetarian and vegan fare.

Amici Italian Grill -

280 Main St. - Middletown

Amici Italian Grill's dimly lit dining room makes for a great dinner date option, but it's also relaxing enough for just a night out with friends.

Cantina Cafe Ristorante -

74 Court Street - Middletown

Dining at the Cantina in Middletown is so much like being invited over to a close relative's house that it seems ungracious to criticize.

Tuscany Grill -

120 College St. - Middletown

This Italian restaurant is a favorite lunch and dinner spot for Main Street shoppers and Wesleyan students.

Deals & Specials:

• Happy Hour

First and Last Tavern -

220 Main St. - Middletown

First & Last does best with traditional interpretations of Italian classics.

Fiore II -

322 Main Street - Middletown

Fiore II in Middletown is very low–key. Just a couple waiters in a small dining room, no blaring opera, no over-the-top Tuscan-theme decor.